My Discipline Style

“Five Basic Needs” of students:
The Five basic needs of Dr. Glasser are survival, love and belonging, power, freedom, and
fun.  When a student acts out, it is because one of these needs is being frustrated in his life.
The teacher’s job is to find out which need is being frustrated, and then find a solution to help
the student.  Survival has to do with food and shelter.  It is more of a physical need.  If that
need for survival is not met, a teacher can’t even begin to address the other 4 needs which
are psychological.  The Love and belonging need can be nurtured by having students work in
groups or by having regular class meetings where the students can offer valuable input.  The
need for power can be met by making sure every student has success.  The freedom need
can be met by making sure we. as teachers, are not dictators, and that we give our students
a choices.  The need for fun can be met by making sure our lessons are interesting to the
students.  This means that we have to ask questions as to what kinds of things they like to
do, etc…


“Six Step Approach for reaching out to students:
The 6 step approach was formulated by Dr. Glasser.  The message in this approach tells a
student they we care as teachers.  The first and most important step is “Building a
Relationship”.  Having a caring relationship with a student before any trouble occurs, makes it
a lot easier to problem solve with that student if trouble should arise.  The student will then
trust the teacher and be willing to work out a solution.  The second step is “Identifying the
Problem”.  It’s important for the student to know specifically what he did wrong and why it was
inappropriate.  If the student doesn’t know what he did wrong, the teacher should specifically
tell him what she witnessed.  The third step is “Analyzing the behavior in terms of needs”.  
This is where the teacher can empathize with the student about what need is lacking in his
life.  The teacher can even educate the student on needs and how they are very normal and
important in everyone’s life.  The fourth step is “Determining alternate behavior”.  This is
where we talk with the student about what he is trying to accomplish by doing this behavior.  
We must then try and lead him to a conclusion that his behavior is not going to get him what
he really wants in the end.  The fifth step is “Creating a plan”.  It’s important to look to the
future and not dwell on what the student did wrong.  If the student cannot come up with a plan
for new behavior, we must help him find one.  The sixth step is “Following up”.  It’s important
to make sure we tell the student that we will talk with him in a few days or so to make sure our
plan is working.  This lets him know that we are not going to just drop him.  It also provides a
time for us to come up with a new plan if ours is not working.


Differences between an effective discipline plan, and an
ineffective discipline plan:
An ineffective discipline plan focuses on the negative behavior without helping the student
come up with a good alternate behavior.  Ineffective rules focus on unwanted negative
behavior.  Ineffective consequences punish the student.  By doing that, the student has
learned nothing.  This type of discipline also creates animosity between the student and
teacher.  The student may even try to revenge the teacher at a later time.  There is no kind of
caring relationship with this type of discipline, and relationship building is the key to
successful discipline.  Punishing a student has detrimental effects on the student’s needs.  It
actually frustrates their needs even further.  An effective discipline plan, on the other hand,
creates a caring atmosphere and teaches the student how to problem solve and get along in
a group.  Rules are basically life rules such as “be considerate of others”, take care of your
classroom, etc…  Positive boundaries are set up so that the students know just how far they
can go.  Consequences focus on brainstorming a new plan for positive behavior.  By learning
these skills, the students gain confidence in themselves as being an important part of the
group.  Students then choose appropriate behavior because they want to belong to their
group.


An effective teaching time-out;
A teaching-time out is a place where the student can go to figure out a new plan for
appropriate behavior.  It is not meant as a punishment or a time to embarrass the student.  
Timeouts are given in a matter of fact manner, but are given swiftly, as soon as the
unacceptable behavior happens.  For younger students there may be a form for them to fill
out to guide them through the planning of future positive behavior.  Older students can just be
kept after class to talk with the teacher about the new plan.  In both scenarios it is important
to get a commitment from the student as to the new plan for behavior.   It is also important
that the student be allowed to take all the time that he needs to come up with a plan and/or to
talk with the teacher.  If the school‘s policy require the student to be sent to the principal’s
office, the student will still have to have a plan for the teacher before he is allowed to come
back to class.  If a student cannot come up with a plan, the teacher must offer suggestions.  
The teacher must also keep in mind what need is being frustrated and help to satisfy that
need.  


High school age students and Elementary aged students?
High school students are under a lot pressure these days due to family divorces, media
violence, and peer pressure.  These students need for school to be a soft place to land.  
However, since many of them have role models that are absent, they rely on outside sources
for their behavior when dealing with conflict and their loss of power.  High school problems
tend to be things like talking back, stealing, and physical fighting.  A student who talks back
has a frustrated need for power.  It’s important to talk with this student, ask what is bothering
him, and offer him a safe place to go until he feels he can come back to class.  Stealing can
be due to a frustrated need for power and/or love and belonging.  Sometimes a student will
steal to impress his friends.  The teacher should address the problem in a class meeting and
encourage someone to come forward if they know who did the stealing.  When the teacher is
absolutely sure who did it, she should confront the student in private and try and figure out
why he stole, and then come up with a replacement plan.  Students who fight in school are
usually unsuccessful in school and so are very frustrated.  Using the 6 step approach to
fighting involves finding out, one on one, what happened, and then coming up with more
appropriate non-violent ways to solve the conflict.

Elementary students seem to have problems such as bullying, talking, and cheating.  With
bullying, it is important to address the needs of the bully as well as the victim, because both
are hurting.  The bully may have come from a violent home and doesn’t know of any other
way to become accepted.  The teacher must teach the bully appropriate ways to be
accepted.   With the talker, the student usually has low self esteem and is trying to fulfill his
need for love and belonging, or power, or freedom.  The teacher needs to have a relationship
with the student to determine what is involved.  Then the 6 step approach should be
followed.  With cheating, it usually stems from a desire to please the parents, or the student
is having trouble with the material.  Either way, it is the teacher’s job to offer the student
some help, and to make sure the student knows he can come to the teacher if he is struggling.


Elements of an effective class meeting:
Class meetings can be educational, open ended, or problem solving.  Educational meetings
have to do with the lessons being taught.  Students are given an opportunity to reflect on
what they have learned, to offer suggestions to homework requirements, and to critique the
way the lesson was presented.  Open ended meetings can be about anything the students
would like to talk about.  This creates a relaxed relationship between students and teacher,
and the students and themselves.  The problem solving meeting discusses issues within in
the classroom dynamics such as sharing, talking, respect, etc.  This kind of meeting can
occur either before an incident or after an incident occurs.  The teacher’s job in a class
meeting is to remain objective and act as a springboard for the class, not a dictator.  
Teachers should allow the class to come up with suggestions.  This makes them feel as
though they have ownership in the classroom.  Teachers should not pass judgement, whether
good or bad, on any comments made by the students.  The teacher should, however, make
sure that students’ comments are always respectful of others.  Every class meeting should
have a topic that is defined by the teacher at the beginning of the meeting.  Then the students
should be encouraged to share their experiences and ideas.  At the end of the meeting the
teacher should try to ask open ended questions to get the students thinking outside the box.  


Middle School aged students:
Middle Schoolers have a lot on their plate.  They are in a new school; hormones are unstable;
they now have more than one teacher to deal with, and they are between childhood and
adulthood.  With all this pressure, most middle schoolers look to their peers for acceptance.  
Defiant behavior escalates as they show their peers that they can handle all that life has given
them.  It is our job as teachers to let them know that they can depend on us to help them
through this tough time.  A “Do Nothing” student usually feels as though they just can’t
succeed in school.  We need to chunk their assignments and follow up with them.  This will
build their confidence.  The “Talking Back” student feels powerless, as if no one is listening to
them.  Class meetings are an excellent way to allow these students to be heard.  These
students also need to be given choices as to who they will work with and how they will
complete tasks.  Basically, they need to be heard.  Teachers must also remember to never
embarrass a student in class.  This will create feelings of resentment between the teacher
and student.  Any delicate issues should be discussed in private.  Vandalism in schools
needs to be handled the same way.  Talk with the student as to why he did the vandalizing.  
Have him clean it up after school.  As a preventative, have class meetings about school
pride, and have classroom awards for clean areas and desks.





ADD and student classroom behavior? (Attention Deficit Disorder):
Students with ADD have difficulty staying on task.  If they get distracted, they can lose their
train of thought.  They cannot always understand directions correctly.  They should not be
reprimanded for that.  Many times when you are talking with them, they are not concentrating
on what you are saying.  They also lose important items such as homework, house keys, and
books.  Teachers must be very understanding with the ADD student.  We must encourage
their strong points so that we can help to build their confidence; give them lots of
manipulatives in order for them to better understand the lessons; make sure we are
communicating with the parents; give the students constructive feedback as soon as the task
is completed; give the student lots of choices in every aspect of the classroom; and help the
student create new plans while in the teaching timeouts.  The author of this course believes
that ADD can be attributed to the 5 basic needs being frustrated.  Having known adults with
ADD, I tend to believe he is correct.  Given that, teachers need to make sure their lessons
speak to every one of the 5 basic needs.